KC
DEN
IND
@MIA
@LV
LAC
@SEA
NYJ
@ATL
ARI
@BUF
@LAR
@CIN
NE
SFNoah Gray (TE, KC) — 2026 evaluation
Scoring note: the evaluation request assumed full PPR / 4pt pass TD because league-settings carried placeholders; methodology/league-settings.md was confirmed 2026-07-08: half PPR (0.5/rec), 6pt pass TD, no TE premium — this eval uses the confirmed settings (full-PPR equivalents given below). No TE reception premium means punt-tier is the league's default TE posture (te.md §7) — which lowers, not raises, the bar Gray fails to clear.
Verdict
AVOID (high confidence), judged against an undrafted price (no FFC ADP value, FFC 2026-07-07; Sleeper search-rank tail, 2026-07-08). Gray fails the te.md §2 route-participation gate outright — 52.1% snap share and on-field for only 42.7% of charted KC dropbacks in 2025 — and his per-route earning (≤0.139 TPRR, ~0.67 YPRR, 6.7% TS, 0 TD on 37 targets) is bottom-of-position, so the eval terminates in blocking-Y/AVOID territory regardless of everything downstream (te.md §2–3, §8: "no price makes him draftable"). The only market case is the deep-league "Kelce-succession stash," and it buys a depth-chart line, not a role: five seasons of earning data say the routes would out-earn Gray, the higher-pedigree receiving heir (Jared Wiley, 2024 R4, "notably healthy now" — chiefs.com, 2026-07-07) is on the roster, and even Gray's TD-spiked 2024 career year produced just ~5.5 half-PPR PPG — roughly 4 points below the streamer baseline. Why the market is wrong (the sliver of it that stashes him): contingent TE2 value with sub-streamer ceiling output is fully claimable off waivers the week Kelce goes down — even a free draft pick overpays because the bench spot has real opportunity cost. Scarcity placement: below the punt tier — punt-tier requires one elite trait or a live role bet worth 0 to +1.5 PPG; Gray's projected edge vs the streamer baseline is approximately −6.5 PPG.
Bull case
- First in line for the most valuable TE succession in football: Kelce is 37 in his possibly final season, Reid's scheme made the TE the team target leader in 2025, and Gray is the trusted, contracted (through 2027) No. 2 with no draft capital added to the room in 2026.
- 2024 shows a real, if modest, schemed role: career highs 40-437-5 with a 56% snap share — Reid trusts him with motion/leak/goal-line packages, and at 4.55 speed he can run the seam when asked.
- Durable (33 of 34 possible games the last two seasons) and roster-secure (special-teams core, $3M dead cap) — he is guaranteed to be standing there if the Kelce contingency hits on a win-total-10.5 offense.
Bear case
- Fails the position's gate: 52% snap share and 42.7% of dropbacks on-field in 2025 — a run-down/12-personnel deployment. te.md §2 is explicit: RP <55% is a part-time player; no efficiency rescues it — and his efficiency needs rescuing (0.67 YPRR).
- Five-year earning record says the routes would out-earn him: ≤0.139 TPRR, 6.7% TS, 0 TD on 37 targets in 2025; the 2024 "breakout" was a 5-TD spike on 49 targets that fully regressed — the exact small-sample TD trap te.md §10 flags.
- Even the contingency is contested and low-yield: Wiley — the 2024 fourth-rounder who led FBS TEs in TD catches in 2023 — is finally healthy and is the receiving-profile heir; a Kelce absence funnels targets to Rice/Worthy/Walker before any TE2; and Gray's ceiling-role output (~5.5–7 half-PPR PPG) still sits ~2–4 points below the 2025 streamer baseline (TE12 = 8.75 half-PPR PPG + streaming bonus ≈ 9.3 — nflverse weekly.csv, derived 2026-07-08).
Projection & comps
Bottom-up (team volume from data/team-profiles/KC.md, 2026-07-07: ~63.5 plays/gm, ~60% dropback rate → ~646 dropbacks over 17 games):
| Scenario | Routes/role | Targets | Rec | Yds | TD | Half-PPR | Full-PPR equiv. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Floor (20th) | Kelce plays 17; Wiley claims receiving snaps in 12 personnel | ~30 | ~17 | ~150 | 1 | 28 | ~37 |
| Median (50th) | 2025 role repeats: ~40% RP, ~260 routes × 0.14 TPRR | ~36 | ~24 | ~215 | 1–2 | 45 | ~57 |
| Ceiling (80th) | Kelce misses 4–6 games; Gray holds TE1 routes over Wiley | ~50 | ~33 | ~330 | 3 | 75 | ~92 |
Median ≈ 2.6 half-PPR PPG. TDs anchored to usage, not 2024 actuals: his red-zone role is small (0 TD on 37 targets in 2025; the 5 TDs of 2024 came on 49 targets — a spike far above any plausible xTD that fully regressed the next season, the classic TE trap per te.md §10). Games-played risk: low (16 of 17 games in 2025, 17 in 2024 — nflverse snap_counts) — and irrelevant at this projection level.
Comps (sanity check): Noah Gray 2025 (37-21-178-0, 2.0 half-PPR PPG — the base case, self-comp) and Noah Gray 2024 (49-40-437-5, ~5.5 half-PPR PPG — the TD-spiked ceiling case, self-comp), both nflverse pulled 2026-07-07. Archetype comps: Durham Smythe (MIA TE2 years), Josiah Deguara (GB H-back 2021–22), Charlie Woerner (SF/ATL blocking Y) — rotational blocking-lean TE2s who never returned a startable fantasy season (archetype reference; exact stat lines not re-pulled, UNVERIFIED). No entry in data/projections/ to reconcile against (directory not present as of 2026-07-08).
Usage profile (te.md §2 table)
| Metric | 2025 value | Band | Source / note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Route participation (RP) | ~40–43% (proxy: on-field for 266 of 623 charted KC dropbacks = 42.7%; true RP ≤ this after pass-block snaps) | FAIL (<55%) — gate ends the eval | nflverse participation 2025, pulled 2026-07-07 |
| Snap share | 52.1% mean (545 snaps, 16 gm); 2024: 56.4% | Part-time | nflverse snap_counts, pulled 2026-07-07 |
| TPRR | ≤0.139 (37 tgt / 266 pass snaps; ~0.15 if pass-blocks removed) | Concern (<0.14) | derived, same sources |
| YPRR | ~0.67 (178 yds / 266 pass snaps, upper bound on routes) | Concern (<1.0) | derived |
| Target share | 6.7% (2025); 8.6% (2024) | Concern (<12%) | nflverse receiving.csv |
| RZ target share | UNVERIFIED (no play-level pbp or provider export cached); circumstantial: 0 TD on 37 tgt 2025 | Small | — |
| End-zone targets | UNVERIFIED | — | — |
| Detached rate (slot/wide) | UNVERIFIED (no alignment export). Deployment inference: run-snap share (53%) > pass-snap share (42.7%) → run-down/12-personnel lean; on-field alongside Kelce on 30.8% of dropbacks | Inline/blocking lean | nflverse participation, derived 2026-07-08 |
| Pass-block rate | UNVERIFIED | — | — |
| xFP | UNVERIFIED (no provider xFP cached); usage math ≈ 2.5–3 half-PPR PPG | Far below TE streamer range | derived above |
Read: the RP gate fails and the earning rates are concern-band everywhere — this is a Blocking Y / rotational move-TE + special-teams core (led all KC offensive players with 125 ST snaps — chiefs.com, 2026-07-07), the one archetype te.md §8 says is undraftable at any price. Pedigree does not rescue it: 2021 R5 (#162 area, day-3) capital is fully decayed in year 6 (prospect-pedigree §1 decay rule — believe the NFL usage record); combine 6'4"/240, 4.55 forty (NFL.com/nfldraftbuzz prospect pages, fetched 2026-07-08) is adequate speed on a light frame; RAS UNVERIFIED (ras.football lookup failed 2026-07-08). Age 27, NFL season 6 (Sleeper players file, 2026-07-07) — inside the TE peak window, but peak of *this* profile is what 2024 already showed.
Context (from data/team-profiles/KC.md, built 2026-07-07)
- TE room, verified 2026-07-08: Kelce re-signed for his age-37, 14th season (1-yr $12M up to $15M, March 2026 — NFL.com/CBS); Gray TE2 (extension signed Sept 2024, 3-yr/$19.5M through 2027; 2026: $4.74M base, $6.97M cap, $3M dead — Spotrac, fetched 2026-07-08); Wiley TE3 (2024 R4, 12 games in two seasons — rookie ACL, 5 games/28 snaps in 2025 — now "notably healthy"); UDFAs Briningstool/Gyllenborg battle for TE4 (chiefs.com pre-camp breakdown, 2026-07-07). KC added no TE in the 2026 draft (ESPN/PFR draft class per team profile, fetched 2026-07-07).
- Play-caller: Andy Reid retains play-calling with Bieniemy back as OC (A to Z Sports, 2026-01-26). Reid's offense structurally feeds one TE — Kelce led the team with 108 targets / 19.7% TS in 2025 — but only one: Gray got 37 targets on the same field. 12-personnel rate 25.7% (nflverse participation 2025) guarantees Gray snaps, not routes: he shared the field with Kelce on 30.8% of dropbacks and earned 0.139 TPRR from it.
- Offense quality: good and improving — Mahomes back from ACL (medium games-risk; Week 1 "strong possibility" — ESPN, June 2026), win total 10.5 (DraftKings via CBS, 2026-07-01), PBWR 2nd. A functional offense is necessary but nowhere near sufficient for a TE2. Low PA rate (14.9% charted, 2025) removes the easiest TE yards; the target tree above him (Rice, Kelce, Worthy, Walker, Thornton) is fully re-signed/consolidated — vacated targets were absorbed internally, not opened (team profile §hierarchy).
- Contingency math: if Kelce misses time, Kelce's ~6.3 targets/game scatter to Rice/Worthy/Walker first; the TE2-turned-TE1 share historically lands well below the incumbent's. Gray's 2024 season (a near-max version of his role) is the honest template for the contingency — and it wasn't startable.
Tripwires
- Kelce misses multi-week time or retires/IRs → re-run; Gray becomes a waiver-claim streamer consideration only — claim then, do not draft now.
- Camp/preseason: Wiley runs ahead of Gray in receiving/2-TE packages or takes TE2 pass snaps with the 1s → Gray drops to a pure zero; also confirms the succession goes through Wiley.
- Gray traded or released (plausible-adjacent: $6.97M cap, $3M dead — Spotrac) → re-run in the new context; a TE1 job elsewhere would void this eval's role assumptions.
- Beat reports of a designed receiving-role expansion for Gray (detached alignments, Kelce load management under Bieniemy's 12-personnel plans) with preseason RP ≥65% → nudge ceiling and re-check.
- Rice suspension ruling (NFL discipline pending — team profile watch item) → minor for Gray; targets flow to Worthy/Thornton/Kelce first, but re-check the tree if combined with tripwire 1.
Sources
data/stats/2025/&data/stats/2024/— receiving.csv, snap_counts.csv, participation.csv, ngs_receiving.csv, weekly.csv (nflverse via nflreadpy, pulled 2026-07-07): all Gray/Kelce/Wiley usage, snap, target, and derived RP/TPRR/YPRR numbers; 2025 TE half-PPR PPG baseline (TE12 = Hunter Henry 8.75) derived 2026-07-08data/adp/adp_ffc_2026-07-07.csv: Gray absent from FFC mock range (sleeper-searchrank row, no ADP value); TE landscape (McBride 27.6 … Kelce 92.0)data/raw/sleeper/players_2026-07-07.json: age 27 (DOB 1999-04-30), Duke, years_exp 5, depth_chart_order 2, search_rank 999data/team-profiles/KC.md(built 2026-07-07): Reid/Bieniemy, Mahomes ACL status, volume model (~63.5 plays, ~60% dropbacks), 12-personnel 25.7%, PA 14.9%, target hierarchy, Kelce re-signing, 2026 draft class (no TE), win total 10.5- chiefs.com "Pre-Camp Breakdown: Tight Ends" (2026-07-07, fetched 2026-07-08): room composition, Kelce age-37/14th season, Gray 125 ST snaps, Wiley health + pedigree, TE4 battle
- Spotrac Noah Gray contract page (fetched 2026-07-08): 3-yr/$19.5M extension (2024-09-05), 2026 $4.74M base / $6.97M cap / $3M dead
- NFL.com prospect page / nfldraftbuzz (fetched 2026-07-08): 2021 R5 pick, 6'4"/240, 4.55 forty; RAS UNVERIFIED (ras.football lookup failed)
methodology/league-settings.md(confirmed 2026-07-08): half PPR, 6pt pass TD, no TE premium