Pittsburgh Steelers

Mike McCarthy

McCarthy is a west-coast timing caller — pass-friendlier than his run-heavy reputation (DAL 2023 PROE +3.0%, 4th; career raw pass 58.6%, >60% in 13 of 18 seasons), but slow-paced and with a…

Play-caller

Last 3 play-calling stops (skip non-calling years — Kellen Moore called Dallas' plays 2020–22; McCarthy took over calling in 2023):

Stop (team, yrs)PROENeutral pass%Sec/play (neutral)Motion%PA%11 / 12 / 21%Condensed%RB tgt shareWR1 TSInside-10 pass%
DAL 2024UNVERIFIED overall (inside-5 PROE +1.1%, 11th — statrankings via search 2026-07-07; within 21/22 personnel −19.8%/−15.6% — Yahoo, 2024)UNVERIFIED — career pass rate 58.6%, >60% in 4 of 5 Dallas years (CBS Sports, fetched 2026-07-07)UNVERIFIED — slow: 37.7 s real time between plays across Dallas tenure (CBS Sports)~40% through Wk 4 (24th), "significantly less motion in 2024," raised mid-season (Blogging The Boys 2024-10-04; Yahoo/thelandryhat, 2024)UNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIED<20% — no McCarthy offense has hit 20% RB target share in 15+ years (CBS Sports)UNVERIFIED (fed CeeDee Lamb as clear No. 1 — specific share unsourced)UNVERIFIED
DAL 2023+3.0% (4th) (Sharp Football/FantasyLife 2024 Cowboys previews citing 2023 season, fetched 2026-07-07)Top-5 rank ("finished fourth in neutral pass rate"), exact % UNVERIFIED (same source)UNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIED<20% (CBS Sports)UNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIED
GB 2016–18UNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIED — very slow: 42.7 s real time between plays over final four GB years (CBS Sports)UNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIED<20% (same)UNVERIFIEDUNVERIFIED

Reference row — PIT 2025 under Arthur Smith (departed; his scheme claims are void per §2): PROE −0.7% (nfelo, fetched 2026-07-07), raw pass 61.75%, 59.8 plays/gm (nflverse pbp_summary, pulled 2026-07-07); motion 43.4%, PA 18.7% of dropbacks (n=667), personnel 11/12/13/21 = 49.1/30.0/13.0/6.9% of personnel-charted plays (nflverse participation+FTN join, n=1,352 charted plays incl. 1 playoff gm, computed 2026-07-07); RB tgt share 25.4% (132/520 — receiving.csv); WR1 (Metcalf) TS 19.0%.

Read: McCarthy is a west-coast timing caller — pass-friendlier than his run-heavy reputation (DAL 2023 PROE +3.0%, 4th; career raw pass 58.6%, >60% in 13 of 18 seasons), but slow-paced and with a career-long allergy to RB targets (<20% share for 15+ years, vs PIT's 25.4% in 2025 — the single biggest tendency flip on this roster). Expect the Arthur Smith 12/13-personnel gravity (43% multi-TE) to give way to more 11 with hitch/timing routes that feed possession receivers — Pittman's profile (123 hitch routes, 87.5% catch rate in 2025 — CBS Sports) is the scheme fit; Metcalf's downfield iso usage is the open question. First-year install drag applies (§9): expect slower/simpler early, drifting toward McCarthy's true tendencies by midseason, with Rodgers' line-of-scrimmage control as the moderating constant.

Scheme family

His weapons — evaluated players

‹ All play-callers PIT profile ›